Skip to content
Total Center US

The US President's Sweeping Strategy to Reshape the World Order Presents European Nations with a Daunting Choice to Make

A graphic depicting geopolitical change
A visual metaphor for changing world politics.

Over eighty years, the transatlantic bond was anchored in a shared commitment to joint protection and a common set of values centered on democracy, human rights, and the legal order.

That defining era was inaugurated in 1947 during a brief speech by President Harry Truman, who vowed American support to defend Europe from further expansion by the Eastern bloc.

The US led the creation of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, the World Bank, the IMF, and the UN. It embedded itself into what later became known as the "rules-based international order", a system where nation-states subscribed to mutual obligations designed to defend free nations from aggressive autocratic regimes.

Now, the newly published US National Security Strategy (NSS), issued in winter, signals that, from the administration's perspective, that common project has concluded; much of what the world assumed about America's role is finished.

The document refers to the "so-called 'rules-based international order'", placing the latter phrase in scare quotes: a form of delegitimization through typography.

A Change in Policy

Deputy JD Vance cautioned America's partners across the Atlantic of this looming transformation during a speech at the security forum in Munich in the first quarter of 2025.

"He asserted plainly that the genuine danger to Europe did not come from Russia but from internal sources - from those restricting expression, stifling opposition and thereby eroding European democracy," the speech noted. He was sharply condemnatory of the "cosmopolitan elite."

A major European publication described the address as a declaration of "political conflict" against Europe.

Last month's NSS formally incorporates Vance's comments, turning them from speech into formal strategy.

"Undoubtedly America is not anymore the country that promoted the universal principles that have been in place since the conclusion of WWII," notes a previous high-ranking figure from the US State Department and a think tank. "It is transitioning to a distinctly new position."

Consequently, if the world is indeed abandoning that post-war framework, what is it moving towards? And what are the implications for the rest of the world, and especially for Europe?

'We Have a Different World Today'

"Multilateral organizations, particularly the UN, have been characterized by strong anti-US bias, and have failed to advance our or any other specific interest," argues a analyst at a influential conservative policy institute.

From her perspective - she previously served as Deputy National Security Adviser to the former President - change to the international order is inevitable in a changing world.

"An additional factor we face is that when that much-discussed global rules system was established after the Second World War, just eight decades past, China was not a primary focus. We now inhabit a new reality."
A moment from post-war diplomacy
The signing of a foundational document.

This rules-based order, built in the aftermath the global conflict, was the creation of a generation that had lived through the catastrophe of Great Power geopolitics and was intent to avert its recurrence.

That order, imperfect and unfinished though it certainly had been, was the legacy of that shared history.

However, the NSS explicitly states that US foreign policy veered off course in the subsequent decades - and it criticizes what it calls "the Washington establishment."

"They tied American policy to a network of global organizations, some of which are driven by outright anti-Americanism and many by a supranational agenda that explicitly seeks to undermine individual state sovereignty," it says.

It indicates that from now on, the US will seek to reduce the power of global institutions.

The Primacy of the Nation-State

"The core actor in international relations is and will remain the sovereign country… We stand for the independent authority of nations, against the sovereignty-sapping incursions of the most interfering international agencies…"

In another section, considering the "balance of power", it states: "The outsized influence of larger, richer, and stronger nations is a permanent feature of world politics."

The Kremlin commented on the review with approval, stating that much of it matched Moscow's own thinking.

"In my view the leaders of the US, China, and Russia and their supportive regimes are seeking to revert to an era of major power rivalry," says a ex-chief of the United Kingdom's defense establishment.

Yet, a renowned professor in War Studies believes the new Security Strategy is not such a fundamental shift with the past as it may appear.

"We must be cautious about the term, which is a concept that gained widespread currency in the last ten years," he suggests. "Look back and you find plenty of violations of the rules, Southeast Asian conflicts for example. So there's a certain nostalgic idealization about the past at times and everyone should be wary of sentimentality for what was a complex past."

A Powerful Revival of Sovereign Power

America's armed intervention in the Venezuelan capital Caracas that led to the apprehension of the country's leader Maduro is an initial instance of this more forceful application of independent action.

Some international law experts have questioned the legality of the US intervention, arguing it may have violated UN charters governing the use of force.

American officials argue its actions were legally justified.

"Under American law it certainly was [legal]," a former Undersecretary of Defense has stated. "He - most of our allies in Europe have not acknowledged his government so he is an usurper. Because of that he is deprived of the standard safeguards that heads of state would have...especially considering domestic laws that exist in the United States, that would supersede anything the UN says."
US influence in Latin America
A representation of hemispheric politics.

The NSS claims, for the United States, the right to be the dominant force in the Western Hemisphere, and to encourage its Latin American and Caribbean neighbours into conformity with Washington's interests.

This is a forceful revival of the

Written by

Elizabeth Mclean

A tech entrepreneur and writer with over a decade of experience in digital transformation and startup ecosystems.

Total Center US

Type to search articles.